Published Articles
  1. BNA Program on Gray Market and Counterfeit Goods

    BNA Program on Gray Market and Counterfeit Goods

     
    Andrew will moderate a webinar on Wednesday October 26,2011, sponsored by BNA entitled Alternatives Now Available to Copyright and Trademark Owners to Combat Gray Market and Counterfeit Goods: Recent First Sale and Related Litigation. The 90-minute program will focus on recent 9th and 2d Circuit cases involving the clash between the first sale doctrine and Section 602(a)(1) of the Copyright Act barring the importation of goods made abroad without the copyright holder’s consent.

    Share
    Read more

  2. PLI Seminar on November 1 on the First Sale Doctrine after Wiley v. Kirtsaeng

    PLI Seminar on November 1 on the First Sale Doctrine after Wiley v. Kirtsaeng

     
    Andrew will be a panelist in a webinar on November 1 sponsored by PLI dealing with the tension between Sections 109(a) and 602(a)(1) of the Copyright Act following the Second Circuit’s decision in John Wiley v. Kirtsaeng. Other panelists are William Dunnegan who represented John Wiley in this case and John T. Mitchell.
    Sections 109 and 602 are in tension because they lead to opposing results.  Section 109, the first sale doctrine, provides that a copyright holder loses control over the distribution of goods once the holder makes a first sale.

    Share
    Read more

  3. Kirtsaeng Asks for En Banc Review; Let’s Hope He Gets It

    Kirtsaeng Asks for En Banc Review; Let’s Hope He Gets It


    Today Mr. Kirtsaeng asked for en banc review of the 2-1 majority opinion by the 2d Circuit in a copyright infringement case brought by John Wiley holding that the first sale doctrine is inapplicable to goods made abroad even if they were imported into the U.S. with the permission of the copyright holder. The petition is here.

    Share
    Read more

  4. The Wait For Kirtsaeng Is Over: The 2d Circuit Holds, Consistent With The 9th Circuit’s Opinion In Omega v. Costco, That The First Sale Doctrine Applies Only To Goods Manufactured In This Country

    The Wait For Kirtsaeng Is Over: The 2d Circuit Holds, Consistent With The 9th Circuit’s Opinion In Omega v. Costco, That The First Sale Doctrine Applies Only To Goods Manufactured In This Country


    §602 (a)(1) Trumps the First Sale Doctrine
    The cloud lingering over the gray market industry since the Supreme Court split 4-4 in Costco just got a lot darker. Gray market goods are those made by the copyright holder abroad and then imported into this country without the permission of the copyright holder. Just last week it seemed the 2d Circuit would never decide John Wiley v.

    Share
    Read more

  5. Waiting for Kirtsaeng: the Unresolved Tension Following the 4-4 Split in Costco Between Sections 602 and 109 of the Copyright Act

    Waiting for Kirtsaeng: the Unresolved Tension Following the 4-4 Split in Costco Between Sections 602 and 109 of the Copyright Act


    The huge gray market industry, disappointed with the Supreme Court’s 4-4 split in Costco v. Omega, has been hoping for better news from the 2nd Circuit. They keep waiting and hoping.
    Different panels of the 2nd Circuit have now heard argument in three cases raising identical issues to those raised but not decided in Costco. But the 2nd Circuit has not decided any of these cases, even though the earliest, John Wiley v.

    Share
    Read more

  6. A Program on the First Sale Doctrine Sponsored by the ABA Forum on the Entertainment and Sports Industries

    A Program on the First Sale Doctrine Sponsored by the ABA Forum on the Entertainment and Sports Industries

     
    Andrew will be a panelist at a webinar on the first sale doctrine sponsored by the American Bar Association Forum on the Entertainment and Sports Industries and the ABA Center for Continuing Legal Education. The program is entitled: The First Sale Doctrine After Costco and Vernor:  Where Do We Go From Here?
    The webinar will take place on Thursday, July 28, 2011 from 12:00 PM – 1:30 PM Eastern Standard Time.  For more information, please click here.

    Share
    Read more

  7. Hot Topics In IP Litigation Program Coming to D.C.

    Hot Topics In IP Litigation Program Coming to D.C.

     
    The IP Litigation Committee of the ABA Section of Litigation is sponsoring its first Hot Topics program to be held on Friday June 10 in DC. The program brochure is here.
    The program will cover the bases: copyrights, trademarks and patents. The copyright program will focus on the unresolved issues arising from the 4-4 split in Costco v.

    Share
    Read more

  8. A Conversation with Lisa Martens About How Brand Owners Can Combat Counterfeiting

    A Conversation with Lisa Martens About How Brand Owners Can Combat Counterfeiting


    Counterfeits cost brand owners billions of dollars every year. How can brand owners combat this problem? What are the best strategies they can employ and will they work?
    I am delighted that Lisa Martens has given us some expert and helpful advice. Lisa is a Principal in the Southern California office of Fish & Richardson P.C. Her practice emphasizes trademark prosecution and litigation for the food service, health care, biotechnology, computer, Internet, and retail clothing industries.  Her complete bio and contact information are here.

    Share
    Read more

  9. Can We Keep Those Gray Market Goods Out of Here? The Unresolved Tension Between §§ 109 and 602 of the Copyright Act Following the 4-4 Split in Costco v. Omega

    Can We Keep Those Gray Market Goods Out of Here? The Unresolved Tension Between §§ 109 and 602 of the Copyright Act Following the 4-4 Split in Costco v. Omega

     
    The BNA Patent, Trademark & Copyright Journal recently published my article dealing with the aftermath of the deadlock in Costco v. Omega. The article analyzes the policy issues in conflict and provides some guidance about how those in the copyright supply chain-manufacturers, importers, distributors and retailers- can protect themselves from claims under Section 602 of the Copyright Act.

    Share
    Read more

  10. Additional Appeals to Watch in the 2d Circuit in the Aftermath of the Costco/Omega 4-4 Split

    Additional Appeals to Watch in the 2d Circuit in the Aftermath of the Costco/Omega 4-4 Split

     
    I mentioned in my post yesterday that all eyes are on the 2d Circuit as we await the decision in the Kirtsaeng case (district court opinion here) which was argued last May. It involves text book arbitrage: the sale here of books made overseas for distribution there at prices below those charged for books intended for the U.S.

    Share
    Read more

Next Page »

SUBSCRIBE TO THE BLOG